"THE TRADING SCHEMES ACT 1996,
What the Government doesn’t want you to know."



In June 2020 after denying it for years, John Pratt of Hamilton Pratt solicitors (franchise law specialist and solicitors to the owners of the companies) acknowledged that the franchise agreements for both the Maid2clean and Time For You home cleaning franchise networks are not Trading Schemes Act 1996 compliant and therefore not worth the paper they are written on. They have acknowledged this has always been the case since the companies commenced trading. In doing so he was acknowledging that in 2014 he bullied a franchisee into a suicide attempt (that went beyond the point where the franchisee could save himself) by giving a false legal opinion and then made threats of bankruptcy to the franchisee due to the legal costs that would be needed to prove his opinions were false. Hopefully one day he will apologise for that. If you have purchased an agreement with either of these companies or have had the franchise agreement enforced then please contact me.

This site is about what the government doesn’t want you to know about the Trading Schemes Act 1996 and how it 'amended' the law by way of secret memo (available only to the British Franchise Association) and have since been falsifying legal opinions in order to cover up this perversion of justice.


In 1996 the Department of Trade and Industry under a Tory watch forced through The Trading Schemes Act 1996, in spite of the British Franchise Association and top franchise lawyers lobbying them that the legislation was unworkable and would actually do serious harm to international franchise companies without achieving what it was set out to do. To his credit Douglass Hogg, the then Minister, tried to persuade his civil servants to listen to the lawyers but then was moved aside in a reshuffle and the legislation came onto statute in 1997.

Shortly after coming on to Statute, the Labour party were elected. The solicitors and the British Franchise Association had another attempt at lobbying to get this legislation removed from Statute but the DTI took a shortcut. They issued the British Franchise Association with a short note, altering the definition of the law into one where everyone would be exempt, albeit without amending the law properly. The interpretation in this memo is not compatible with the legislation on statute and effectively changes the law.

 Here is the short note/memo sent to the British Franchise Association which secretly amended the legislation

Franchise companies now knew they couldn’t be prosecuted by the DTI, but letters from the British Franchise Association pointing out that the DTI had no influence on civil courts were ignored.

When some Chem-Dry franchisees made a complaint that their Master Franchises were breeching the Trading Schemes Act 1996 the Department of Trade and industry simply ignored them.

 Click here to view the hansard report

When it became obvious they weren’t going away they falsified a legal opinion to reflect the interpretation they had offered in the short note.

On the 13th June 2016, having acknowledged to James Heappey MP that the law does need changing, someone called Paul Davison, a Senior Private secretary at the Business Department wrote to say that there is relatively low volumes (of correspondence) on the issue. What he doesn’t say (and attempts to point it out are ignored) is that the Business Departments website has said for several years that they wont accept any complaints about Trading Schemes Act legislation or indeed any complaints on anything from members of the public.

On April 10th 2019 the current ill-informed Minister Kelly Tolland MP wrote to James Heappey MP stating that enforcement of trading Schemes Act legislation is by local authority trading standards services. This is complete nonsense, enforcement is with the Business Department of which Kelly Tolland MP is in charge of and Trading Standards have no authority for the act. Both James Heappey and Kelly Tolland are currently ignoring this false claim.

It is unclear why our MP’s are so determined to cover up for dodgy Civil Servants at the expense of their constituents, the very people they are elected to represent?


STATEMENT ON LEGAL OPINION FROM BISS

(Formerly Department of Trade and Industry)

In summary, the legislation for franchising is that if there are two master franchises for an international franchise system then the Trading Schemes Act 1996 regulations apply (written parliamentary answer 14th Feb 2002.) But the Department of Trade and Industry obtained a legal opinion which states that if there are two master franchises then each master franchise is in its own scheme.
The legislation is clear that a trading scheme can only be exempt from the framework when it has a single master franchiser in the UK, if all the UK participants are registered for VAT or if the scheme is a chain letter with no central organiser or beneficiary.   

Regarding the specific example of Chem-Dry which is Mr Arnold’s concern, the Department has previously advised Mr Arnold that its view when considering his complaint was that there were two separate and distinct trading schemes in the UK - one operated by Chem-Dry Northern & Southern Limited and the other by Chem-Dry Midlands and London Limited. The Department’s view was that both of these schemes were exempt from the provisions of the legislation by virtue of the single tier exemption.   

It is not therefore the case that the Department has suggested that a trading scheme with two master franchisers could be covered by the single tier exemption; rather the Department considered that there were two separate schemes in the UK, each with one master franchiser and each of which was covered by the single-tier exemption.

This legal opinion is clearly nonsense as if it were true and each master franchise is in its own scheme then there could never be two master franchises in the same scheme and everyone would be exempt from the legislation.

Similar false legal opinions have been offered for Pyramid schemes over the years, making The Trading Schemes Act 1996 effectively null and void. Everybody knows this is the case but everybody seems happy that it is covered up.

The false legal opinion was the test case for the Freedom of Information Act 2000. The case Bellamy v The Information Commissioner found that legal privilege is paramount, even though the case was really about the abuse of legal privilege in obtaining legal opinions purely for the purpose of not having to explain the actions. Bellamy v The Information Commissioner was based on a falsified legal opinion.

If you have suffered as a result of the Trading Schemes Act 1996 then please contact info@tradingschemesact.co.uk for free advice on the truth which you wont get from a solicitor.



Bookmark and Share